Performance Bonuses Demystified: What Product Managers Need to Know

For many, performance-based bonuses comprise a significant proportion of their total compensation package. Understanding the nuance of this specific type of compensation can create the difference between receiving a large bonus when performance goals are met, and not. A bonus is an additional financial incentive based on the overall performance or specific achievements of a Product Manager over a given time period. These are two primary forms of bonuses:

• Performance Bonuses - typically cash payments that are given to employees based on the achievement of predefined performance targets. These targets can be individual, team, or company-wide.
  
  
• Spot Bonuses - a one-time bonus given for exceptional work or contributions that go above and beyond the regular job description or responsibilities. Spot bonuses are typically awarded without prior expectation or set criteria.

‍

There is a third form of bonus offered to Product Managers, called sign-on bonuses. Often found with unique contractual agreements, we cover this in more detail in our article: The Hidden Strings: A Closer Look at Sign-On Bonuses.

As spot bonuses are generally considered to be less contractual, therefore more variable in their nature, this article will focus on performance-based bonuses. The specifics around performance-based bonuses that will be discussed include:

• Bonuses as part of your total compensation,
• Setting measurable criteria for earning bonuses, 
• The benefits of performance bonuses,
• The challenges of performance bonuses, 
• Industry standards for bonuses.

Before focusing specifically on this one form of compensation, Product Managers should be aware of the 7 types of compensation typically offered. This broader awareness will ensure you maximise your total  compensation package in response to your needs and goals. It is also important to understand how the salary of a Product Manager may be influenced by several factors. 

As a Product Manager, you should understand that performance-based bonuses serve as a variable component that can significantly increase your total earnings in a given year based on the achievement of specific goals. Furthermore, in most jurisdictions, performance-based bonuses are taxed as income and therefore the take-home pay from a bonus will be less than the amount paid. The advice offered in this regard is to consider consulting with a tax professional to plan for the potential tax implications of your performance-based bonuses.

As mentioned, performance-based bonuses (when included in your total compensation package) should be laid out within your employment contract. Consequently, you should become familiar with the bonus criteria basics, and work with your employer to set clear and measurable targets for earning your bonuses.

Begin by distinguishing the difference between objective criteria (quantifiable and measurable) from subjective criteria (based on personal judgement like leadership qualities). Where possible, you should emphasise the importance of having a balance between the criteria types, but focus more on objective criteria for transparency and fairness. Doing so will ensure you have a continued ability throughout the specified time period to assess your progress in relation to those criteria and make measured changes to move closer to your goal. 

As part of your compensation negotiations, you should help shape the criteria tied to your bonuses. When designing effective bonus criteria, you should aim to use a goal setting framework such as SMART. Through such a framework, each of your goals tied directly to your performance bonus will contain the following parameters, ensuring it is both clear and attainable:

• Specific - goals should be clear and specific to avoid ambiguity and ensure understanding. Specific goals answer the "what, why, and how" of the objectives. For instance, instead of saying "improve product performance," a specific goal would be "increase user engagement on the product feature X by 20%."
  
  
• Measurable - goals are defined through parameters that can quantify progress and completion. This involves identifying data or metrics that will demonstrate achievement. For example, measuring the increase in user engagement can be done through analytics tools that track user activity.
  
  
• Achievable - goals are realistic and attainable within the given resources, timeframe, and starting point. They should stretch the abilities of the employee to achieve them but still remain within reach to avoid discouragement.
  
  
• Relevant - goals are aligned with broader business objectives, team roles, and individual career paths. They should matter to the business and to the individuals working towards them. For instance, increasing user engagement should tie into broader company goals like improving customer satisfaction or increasing sales.
  
  
• Time-Bound - goals should have a clear timeline or deadline to create urgency and prompt action. This helps prevent daily tasks from taking precedence over longer-term objectives.

Having established a set of transparent and effective goals, you should suggest implementing regular feedback mechanisms which allows both yourself and your employers to review the progress toward achieving performance-based goals alongside reviewing the effectiveness of the bonus criteria to ensure they remain aligned with business goals and your capabilities and responsibilities outlined within your job description. This is recommended every 6 months to 1 year, depending on the industry, company type, and company size.

Performance-based bonuses provide you, the Product Manager, with a direct financial incentive to achieve and exceed your goals. This form of compensation can act as a significant motivation boost as there is a direct and tangible reward linked directly to your efforts.

Particularly in competitive job markets, companies offering substantial performance bonuses can attract top talent. This should be seen as a company’s desire and willingness to reward hard work and success. Furthermore, attractive bonuses packages can play a critical role in retaining top performers due to their efforts being recognised and rewarded, reducing turnover within teams.

Unlike fixed salaries, bonuses are typically paid out when specific business objectives are met, making them a cost-effective way to manage compensation for individuals such as Product Managers who are able to fetch a premium salary. 

Understanding the benefits companies can draw from performance-based bonuses will support you, as a Product Manager, to negotiate an overall higher total compensation package and maximise your salary.

Particularly if working for an early-stage, or rapidly growing start-up company, Product Managers can be presented with particularly attractive bonus packages. With the upside of performance-based bonuses yielding a higher total compensation package, there are several key challenges which should be addressed. 

Regardless of the industry, company size, or type there will always be a dependence on external factors. Sometimes, these external factors (such as market changes or an economic downturn) can impact a Product Managers ability to deliver and meet the outlined bonus criteria. This can be particularly challenging when these externalities are not accounted for at the time bonuses were designed. There can often be inflexibility in adjust bonus criteria in response to these unforeseen circumstances which result in unfair penalties for employees who might have otherwise performed exceptionally under normal conditions. 

For Product Managers, often overseeing the delivery or roadmaps and sprints, there may be increased pressure to meet bonus criteria leading to increased stress and burnout among team members. Understanding how both your bonuses, and the bonuses of other individuals within your team(s) can create friction and stress, particularly when goals are linked more directly to the over team performance may increase the difficulty in reaching outlined criteria. 

Creating SMART goals and undertaking regular reviews can reduce these common challenges, and being continuously aware of the implications they can have on your personal and professional situation will help in mitigating the negative impact they may otherwise have caused.

Performance-based bonuses may differ significantly between industries for a variety of reasons including revenue potential and industry complexity. For example, the finance and banking sector traditionally relies heavily on performance bonuses, with those bonuses sometimes exceeding the base salaries offered. Compare this to the healthcare industry where bonuses are more conservative, but closely tied to regulatory achievements. 

Some of the key difference in bonus, depending on industry include:

• Variability in bonus size - the size of performance bonuses can vary widely, not just between industries but also within them, depending on the company's size, profit margins, and strategic priorities.
  
  
• Payout frequency - while some industries might offer annual bonus payouts, others might provide quarterly or even monthly bonuses to align more closely with operational cycles and motivate ongoing performance.
  
  
• Cash vs equity-based bonuses - particularly in startups and tech companies, there's a noticeable shift from cash bonuses to equity-based compensation, which aligns long-term employee interests with the company’s success.
  
  
• Performance measurement - with the increasing adoption of data analytics, the metrics used to determine bonuses are becoming more sophisticated, moving beyond simple revenue or profit targets to include factors like customer satisfaction, team engagement, and innovation.

Equipped with this appreciation for how performance-based bonuses can vary depending upon industry and company, you can feel confident in negotiating a total compensation package which is more accepted within your given field, while still satisfying your needs and expectations.

Performance-based bonuses are objectives aligned closely with the overarching business goals of your organisation. Employers are able to leverage these bonuses to incentivise behaviours and outcomes which directly contribute towards the company’s success. As discussed, these bonuses offer significant benefits to both you, the Product Manager, and your employer which can add value to your overall compensation package. However, the challenges faced with external factors and managing team dynamics should be taken into consideration particularly if you’re new to a company. 

Regardless of industry, performance-based bonuses offer an exciting addition to any compensation package and when designed carefully with clear and transparent objectives can serve as great additional motivation to any Product Manager.